Homes for sale in Shelter Island, NY
31 homes
New today$6,395,000
5 bd 路 7 ba 路 4,250 sqft
8 Margarets Dr, Shelter Island
$1,325,000
3 bd 路 2 ba 路 1,663 sqft
11 Ole Buck Run, Shelter Island
$900,000
2 bd 路 1 ba 路 936 sqft
17 Brander Pkwy, Shelter Island
$4,800,000
4 bd 路 3 ba 路 3,490 sqft
140 N Ferry Rd, Shelter Island
$3,250,000
4 bd 路 3 ba 路 3,097 sqft
20 Baldwin Rd, Shelter Island
$1,999,999
4 bd 路 3.5 ba 路 2,777 sqft
5 Marc St, Shelter Island
$1,750,000
3 bd 路 2 ba 路 1,500 sqft
9 Crab Creek Rd, Shelter Island
Price cut $260,000$2,690,000
4 bd 路 3 ba 路 2,289 sqft
7 Wheeler Rd, Shelter Island
$1,999,999
6 bd 路 6 ba 路 6,098 sqft
4 Bayview Ave, Shelter Island
$845,000
3 bd 路 1 ba 路 901 sqft
3 Osprey Rd, Shelter Island
$4,350,000
4 bd 路 4 ba 路 2,562 sqft
76 Smith St, Shelter Island
$1,685,000
3 bd 路 2 ba 路 1,424 sqft
6 Cozy Ln, Shelter Island
$3,400,000
4 bd 路 5 ba 路 4,901 sqft
20 Sunshine Rd, Shelter Island
No photo
Price cut $120,000$1,180,000
3 bd 路 2 ba 路 1,242 sqft
12 Ginny Dr, Shelter Island
$4,250,000
4 bd 路 4.5 ba 路 3,500 sqft
169 N Ferry Rd, Shelter Island
$4,250,000
4 bd 路 4.5 ba 路 3,500 sqft
169 N Ferry Rd, Shelter Island
$8,500,000
3 bd 路 2.5 ba 路 1,798 sqft
3 Bevan Pl, Shelter Island
$4,995,000
5 bd 路 6.5 ba 路 5,535 sqft
6 Great Circle Dr, Shelter Island
$2,199,000
5 bd 路 4 ba 路 2,642 sqft
64A N Midway Rd, Shelter Island
Price cut $145,000$1,950,000
4 bd 路 2.5 ba 路 3,059 sqft
14 Crescent Way, Shelter Island
Pending$2,230,000
5 bd 路 4 ba 路 3,262 sqft
61 N Cartwright Rd, Shelter Island
No photo
Pending$8,995,000
3 bd 路 4 ba 路 3,801 sqft
8C Pheasant Cir, Shelter Island
Pending$2,790,000
4 bd 路 2.5 ba 路 2,890 sqft
24 Rocky Point Rd, Shelter Island
Pending$9,995,000
8 bd 路 9.5 ba 路 6,290 sqft
8 Little Ram Island Dr, Shelter Island
There are 20 homes for sale in Shelter Island, NY, with a median list price of $2,444,500. Prices run from $845,000 to $8,500,000. The newest listings come first. Filter by price, beds, baths and home type, or move the map to look around.
Swipe homes in the app